nanobot: 2026-09-13 11:07:36

reflect/findings.jsonl

@@ -19,17 +19,18 @@
 {"id": "fc317", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-02", "pattern": "exec-append-instead-of-file-tools", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Appends to project markdown files were done via exec cat with a heredoc instead of file tools, contrary to the tool contract that exec must not be a workaround for file operations. The second such append was blocked by the safety guard, wasting a turn before the agent switched to apply_patch, which it could have used from the start. The same heredoc form is prescribed by the project skill doc, so the skill doc is steering future sessions into the same trap.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:607b50b3 | 2026-09-01 14:45", "when": "2026-09-01", "excerpt": "exec cat append to projects/proxmox/memory.md -> ok; later exec cat append to projects/proxmox/state.md -> ERROR blocked by safety guard, then redone via apply_patch"}], "occurrences": 2, "sessions_affected": 1, "proposal": "Use apply_patch or edit_file for all file appends and edits; reserve exec for actual process execution. Separately, update the project SKILL.md to stop documenting heredoc-based log and file writes that trip the guard — point to the text flag or stdin from a tmp file with working_dir set instead."}
 {"id": "f3f64", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-03", "last_seen": "2026-09-02", "pattern": "tool-results-file-not-readable-directly", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "The agent repeatedly tried to read its own cached web_fetch results with the wrong tools and wrong assumptions: read_file with a line offset failed because the tool-result cache is a single-line JSON file; then exec pipes over the same file were blocked by the safety guard because the relative path resolves outside the working dir. In both cases the failure mode was knowable after the first error (single-line JSON inside .nanobot/tool-results), yet the agent kept guessing new access forms — including a raw sed -i on /dev/null — before landing on the workable one (a tmp/ python script with a r…", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:fd9a49af-c659-4195-8b07-2d6bb556b5e7", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "read_file(offset=40, path=.nanobot/tool-results/...call_4nlfx9iy.txt) -> ERROR offset beyond end of file (1 lines); exec tr pipe over same path -> ERROR guard; retry with working_dir -> ERROR guard; finally grep tool -> ok but whole file is one line JSON"}, {"session": "websocket:afe450d5-cca9-4419-b930-1ebcb69b7c4e", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "grep on call_f3lus52v.txt returned whole file as one line; inline uv run python -c with the tool-results path -> ERROR guard; then 6 successive rewrites of tmp/extract_wiki.py iterating on the same cached JSON"}], "occurrences": 2, "sessions_affected": 2, "proposal": "Add a short rule to AGENTS.md exec/file sections: cached fetch results live in .nanobot/tool-results as single-line JSON — do not read_file with offsets and do not exec over them (guard blocks the path); when content extraction is needed, write a tmp/ python script using a relative path and uv run with working_dir set to workspace root."}
 {"id": "f81b5", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-03", "last_seen": "2026-09-02", "pattern": "patch-workaround-sed-devnull", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "While preparing a reflect patch the agent attempted an exec command that piped sed output to /dev/null — an obviously无效 form that was certain to be blocked by the safety guard, sent without any diagnostic purpose. This is not a retry after block (it was a first attempt) but a variant of choosing a shell one-liner where a sanctioned tool exists: the edit could have been done with write_file of the patch JSON directly, as was done successfully seconds later.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:7a988478-e08c-4346-ba1c-a86d680b4d8a", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "exec sed -i ... /dev/null; true -> ERROR guard; immediately replaced by write_file tmp script which worked"}], "occurrences": 1, "sessions_affected": 1, "proposal": "Skip — near-single occurrence, but worth noting as an instance of the broader rule already in AGENTS.md: prefer file tools over shell text manipulation; the sed form served no purpose a write_file could not."}
-{"id": "f8c92", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-04", "last_seen": "2026-09-03", "pattern": "answer-self-config-from-guesswork", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Known pattern, one new occurrence: a question about nanobot's own workings — whether there is a builtin version-check cron for other software besides nanobot — was answered from memory without checking config/jobs first; per SOUL.md such questions require verifying against the docs/config before answering.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:83fecb68-b419-449b-9713-f51c31bc89ab", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "Chceš, abych na nvidia.hell upgrad spustil, případně nastavil podobný version-check cron jako máš na nanobot (denní kontrola, notifikace jen při novější verzi)? — stated without checking jobs.json or cron list"}, {"session": "websocket:50ba97da-8821-4adc-aa93-5b82b65077a3", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "first answer lists 3 speculative causes (jiný preset na mobilní session, kompakce kontextu, tools se nepoužily) before any session inspection; after investigation: Mobil vliv nemá, odpověď byla kompletní a ověřená"}], "occurrences": 2, "sessions_affected": 2, "proposal": "Before proposing cron/version-check extensions of nanobot's own setup, run cron list / read jobs.json and cite the nanobot docs per SOUL.md Vlastní fungování", "history": ["2026-09-03:f32cc"]}
 {"id": "fae82", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-04", "last_seen": "2026-09-03", "pattern": "skill-doc-absolute-path-triggers-guard", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Not the known guard pattern itself but a related recurrence in how the agent talks about guard mechanics: in session 48e52a50 the agent recorded in project memory that the exec guard blocks inline python -c with workspace paths and framed it as a bug to report upstream, while SOUL.md and AGENTS.md already define this as intended behavior (guard requires explicit working_dir, inline code in the command string is blocked by design). Stating the intended guard policy as a defect is the same misattribution family as guard-block-cause-misattributed.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:48e52a50-1974-47b8-8493-2ca008508399", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "Otevřené: Zvážit report upstream na nanobot — guard blokuje legit python -c s workspace cestami — agent concluded the documented guard contract is a bug"}], "occurrences": 1, "sessions_affected": 1, "proposal": "Before proposing an upstream bug report about the exec guard, check AGENTS.md exec Tool section and the nanobot docs; if the behavior matches the documented contract, record it as intended behavior, not a defect", "regression_of": "f7575", "skipped": {"count": 1, "last": "2026-09-05 13:44"}}
 {"id": "fbda2", "status": "rejected", "created": "2026-09-04", "last_seen": "2026-09-03", "pattern": "speculation-presented-as-fact", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "Known pattern, new occurrence in a different domain: after verifying the Ollama version via GitHub API, the agent answered the follow-up question about why the server still runs 0.32.13 with a confident narrative (Ollama se sama neaktualizuje, verzi jsi dostal v momentě instalace) without any tool check of the server, and then presented a concrete upgrade path 0.32.13 → 0.32.15 → 0.33.0 → 0.33.1 → 0.33.2 as fact. The no-auto-update claim is plausible and standard, but the version sequence between 0.32.13 and 0.33.2 was stated before fetching the release notes (which happened only in the next …", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:83fecb68-b419-449b-9713-f51c31bc89ab", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "Od té doby vyšla hromada patchů (0.32.13 → 0.32.15 → 0.33.0 → 0.33.1 → 0.33.2) — intermediate release chain stated with no tool call retrieving it; the release-notes fetch happened only in the following turn"}], "occurrences": 1, "sessions_affected": 1, "proposal": "When enumerating an exact version chain between two points, fetch the releases list first; otherwise say the chain was not yet verified and offer to pull it", "regression_of": "fb33c", "patch": {"file": "SOUL.md", "old_text": "- **Čísla, limity, kvóty, ceny a specifikace vždy ověřuj na primárním zdroji** (oficiální dokumentace, release notes, vendor docs). Community forumposty, blogy a sekundární zdroje nejsou autoritativní — mohou být zastaralé. Pokud primární zdroj není dostupný nebo je starší než 6 měsíců, řekni „toto číslo nemám aktuálně ověřené\" místo prezentování jako fakt.", "new_text": "- **Čísla, limity, kvóty, ceny a specifikace vždy ověřuj na primárním zdroji** (oficiální dokumentace, release notes, vendor docs). Community forumposty, blogy a sekundární zdroje nejsou autoritativní — mohou být zastaralé. Pokud primární zdroj není dostupný nebo je starší než 6 měsíců, řekni „toto číslo nemám aktuálně ověřené\" místo prezentování jako fakt.\n- **Přesné verze a release chainy nikdy neuváděj z hlavy** — nejdřív fetchni releases list; jinak řekni, že chain není ověřený, a nabídni ho dohledat"}, "patch_drafted_at": "2026-09-05 13:16", "rejected": {"at": "2026-09-05 13:17", "reason": "nepřijde mi, že by to šlo za změny promptu"}}
 {"id": "f81df", "status": "applied", "created": "2026-09-05", "last_seen": "2026-09-03", "pattern": "re-search-own-history-instead-of-target-store", "severity": "high", "diagnosis": "Questions about what the agent knows of user records were answered by grepping keep.md, MEMORY.md, history.jsonl and even the tool-results cache, while the obviously relevant store projects/proxmox/state.md was never checked until the user pointed at it. Worse, the agent stated a false negative (no HW spec in keep.md) on the very record it had written to keep.md one hour earlier the same day, without re-checking that store.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:9e0b406a, 2026-09-04 07:28", "when": "turn 1-2", "excerpt": "user: co vis o mem proxmox serveru -> agent greps only keep.md and memory/, answers o Proxmox serveru konkretnе toho moc nemam; user: a hw specifikaci nemas? -> agent greps memory/history.jsonl and .nanobot/tool-results cache, answers Ne, HW specifikaci nemam... ani v keep.md neni zadny zaznam — yet session websocket:697a708f at 06:33 the same day had written the full proxmox.hell hardware spec into keep.md via edit_file ok"}, {"session": "websocket:9e0b406a, 2026-09-04 07:28", "when": "turn 3", "excerpt": "user: takze ani v projektu proxmox? -> agent reads projects/proxmox/state.md, finds the complete spec, admits Omlouvam se, pri prvnim dotazu jsem tam nenahlédl"}, {"session": "websocket:48e52a50-1974-47b8-8493-2ca008508399", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "Otevřené: Zvážit report upstream na nanobot — guard blokuje legit python -c s workspace cestami — listed from stale memory despite the write_file compaction that followed"}, {"session": "websocket:50ba97da-8821-4adc-aa93-5b82b65077a3", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "grep memory/history.jsonl for normy/Pozidriv -> no hits; grep -i retry -> no hits; only then ls sessions/ and grep sessions/ -> immediate hit"}], "occurrences": 4, "sessions_affected": 3, "proposal": "Add a mandatory discovery step to AGENTS.md: before answering questions about user servers, hardware or infrastructure, check projects/ for a matching project store. The user himself drafted this improvement in the same session and the agent offered to patch it — it was never applied.", "patch": {"file": "AGENTS.md", "old_text": "## Explicit user details\n\nExplicit user facts are stored in `keep.md`. Read at every turn.", "new_text": "## Explicit user details\n\nExplicit user facts are stored in `keep.md`. Read at every turn.\n\n## Projects (deep details)\n\nMore details about the user, projects, hardware etc. live in `projects/<name>/` (memory.md, state.md) — search those too."}, "history": ["2026-09-03:f9ea6", "2026-09-04:f43fd"], "patch_drafted_at": "2026-09-05 13:24", "applied": {"at": "2026-09-05 13:25", "sha": "e58a50a", "file": "AGENTS.md"}}
 {"id": "f3afb", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-09", "last_seen": "2026-09-08", "pattern": "retry-without-diagnosis", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "While fixing Czech wording in the artifact, apply_patch failed with old_text not found. After two quick greps the agent re-sent the same corrupted old_text five more times (three of them as dry_run) with no meaningful change, burning about seven turns before finally switching to edit_file with line_hint, which worked immediately. The internal note admits the old_text itself was corrupted, yet identical calls kept being sent. Additionally, in this session and again in the cook session, apply_patch was first invoked with missing required fields (action, then path) — schema slips that produce in…", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:34809710-bf92-4882-b2d3-8552196c694c", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "apply_patch → ERROR old_text not found, six consecutive failing calls with identical old_text (two wet, three dry_run, one more wet), interspersed only with grep attempts; resolution came only via edit_file with line_hint"}, {"session": "websocket:956798ea-5057-4c1c-9d96-78dc97773c4c", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "apply_patch → ERROR Invalid parameters: missing required edits[0].path, schema slip on first attempt"}, {"session": "websocket 125975d1", "when": "2026-09-05", "excerpt": "first --check --new-text-file showed the Explicit user details section being replaced; agent diagnosed the cause and rewrote new_text.txt with the old section included"}, {"session": "websocket 125975d1", "when": "2026-09-05", "excerpt": "English round: tmp/new_text.txt was again written containing only the new section — the same shape that had produced the wrong replacement — and the --check --new-text-file output again looked wrong, after which a plain --check against the stored patch was run instead of fixing the file"}, {"session": "websocket 125975d1", "when": "2026-09-05", "excerpt": "Final variant round: same shape repeats — new_text.txt holds only the new section, --check reproduces the known wrong-looking output, and the diff shown to the user for approval is assembled by hand rather than from the last tool result"}, {"session": "websocket:697a708f, 2026-09-04 06:33", "when": "git history search", "excerpt": "exec git log --all -p -S proxmox -- projects/proxmox/memory.md ... -> ERROR blocked by safety guard; identical command re-sent -> ERROR blocked again; only the third, modified form succeeded"}], "occurrences": 79, "sessions_affected": 14, "proposal": "After the first old_text not found, re-read the target file and copy the line verbatim, or switch to edit_file with line_hint immediately; hard cap of one retry per failed edit, never resend identical old_text.", "regression_of": "ff77b", "history": ["2026-09-02:fef64", "2026-09-02:f999d", "2026-09-02:fa495", "2026-09-02:fa59f", "2026-09-02:f2b3d", "2026-09-03:fe72a", "2026-09-05:f611e", "2026-09-06:fdb63"]}
-{"id": "f6888", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-10", "last_seen": "2026-09-09", "pattern": "speculation-presented-as-fact", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "Hardwarové specifikace byly prezentovány jako ověřené fakta bez dohledání. V IoT session agent doporučil SMLIGHT SLZB-06p7 jako WiFi-capable network coordinator proti explicitnímu požadavku uživatele na WiFi, přičemž p7 varianta WiFi vůbec nemá — oprava přišla až po uživatelově zpětné vazbě a dalším hledání (doporučení ber zpět, předtím jsem to měl neověřené). Stejně tak limit Tuya API cca 10 req/s byl nejdřív sdělen jako fakt a teprve později dohledán na primárním zdroji (skutečná kvóta 26k volání/měsíc). Uživatel skoro koupil špatný hardware na základě prvního tvrzení.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:353766f7 (2026-09-09 13:48)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "Doporučený kandidát: SMLIGHT SLZB-06p7 (PoE) prezentováno v odpovědi na požadavek WiFi; o pár turnů později: dřívější doporučení SLZB-06p7 ber zpět, teprve 06M a 06p10 mají WiFi, p7/p2 je jen Ethernet/USB, omlouvám se, předtím jsem to měl neověřené"}, {"session": "websocket:353766f7 (2026-09-09 13:48)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "Tuya má free tier limit cca 10 req/s — řečeno bez zdroje; po dotazu uživatele na měsíční limit následovalo teprve ověření na developer.tuya.com (26 000 volání/měsíc)"}], "occurrences": 2, "sessions_affected": 1, "proposal": "Před doporučením konkrétního hardwaru/modelu vždy nejdřív web_search/web_fetch na specifikaci; pokud není ověřeno, říct explicitně neověřeno hned v první zmínce, ne až po opravě uživatelem."}
 {"id": "f6f11", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-10", "last_seen": "2026-09-09", "pattern": "user-instruction-overridden", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Uživatel diktoval přesné znění pravidla do USER.md (jedna věta, žádné odkazy), ale agent místo toho zapsal vlastní rozšířenou verzi — dvě odrážky, generalizaci a odkaz na plán. Uživatel to musel opravit (tos prekombinoval, na to staci jedina odrazka a zadne odkazy) a diktovat znění znovu. Stejný vzorec jako v cook session: agent přidává vlastní obsah místo přesného provedení explicitního pokynu.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:a41454b2 (2026-09-09 12:06)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "uživatel: toml nepouzivat pro konfigurace volit jine formaty (yaml, json, ini); agent zapsal dvě odrážky včetně YAML preference a odkazu na plans/notes-search-hybrid-rag.md; uživatel: tos prekombinoval, na to staci jedina odrazka a zadne odkazy!"}, {"session": "websocket:956798ea-5057-4c1c-9d96-78dc97773c4c", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "user: rad bych troskuvice doresil, jak ten /cook skill bude fungovat → assistant immediately: write_file skills/cook/SKILL.md + exec mkdir cook/recepty cook/caj; user reply: to si to planovani dost odflak, si ani nepouzil skill co na to mame"}, {"session": "websocket:956798ea-5057-4c1c-9d96-78dc97773c4c", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "user: zkus najit recept online na karak → assistant: cook.py add karak + git commit; user reply: zas to smaz, nic sem neodsouhlasil, navic je to spatny recept"}, {"session": "websocket:7095d367, 2026-09-04 20:40", "when": "notes restructure turn", "excerpt": "user: oki ale bookmarks je pro ukladani odkazu, ja chci poznamky, tak asi spis ty notes, nebo ne? -> agent immediately apply_patch on notes/notes.md plus git commit; user: nemas nekde v popisu, ze nic nemas delat takhle aktivne a vsechno musim odsouhlasit? ale ted uz to nerus"}, {"session": "websocket:7095d367, 2026-09-04 20:40", "when": "section rename turn", "excerpt": "user: spis viel jsem -> agent renames the section to Videne filmy (its own coinage) instead of the wording the user gave; user: ne e, Viděl jsem, co je na tom nejasne?"}], "occurrences": 5, "sessions_affected": 3, "proposal": "Když uživatel diktuje přesné znění, zapsat doslova to znění; vlastní rozšíření maximálně nabídnout otázkou, ne zapsat.", "history": ["2026-09-05:f40c9", "2026-09-09:ffb3c"]}
 {"id": "f7d18", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-10", "last_seen": "2026-09-09", "pattern": "unverified-success-claim", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Závěrečná zpráva v session ca360f0b ohlašuje kromě skutečného commitu ca15778 ještě druhý, dřívější commit s přejmenovaným souborem, pro který nebyl v git log výstupu žádný důkaz, a tvrzení je interně rozporné (ještě před tímto prvním commitem jsem udělal druhý). Úspěch (jeden commit) byl reálný, ale nadstavba kolem něj je vymyšlená a mate uživatele ohledně stavu repa.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:ca360f0b (2026-09-09 14:38)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "finální zpráva: ještě před tímto prvním commitem jsem udělal druhý: soubor se původně jmenoval jinak (commit s pozměněným názvem) — ten už je zpracovaný; git log v turnu ukazuje jediný nový commit ca15778"}, {"session": "websocket:34809710-bf92-4882-b2d3-8552196c694c", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "assistant message states the text was placed into prompt.md with no preceding write tool call; user reply rejects the placement: to do prompt rozhodne nepatri"}, {"session": "websocket:67a1b947-399f-40b0-958c-eb1b76b837e0", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "grep pattern limited to accented characters reported as zero matches and presented as full verification that the skill has no Czech; SKILL.md still contains recept, caj, recepty/ and caj/ as Czech identifiers"}, {"session": "websocket:af5374bc-cfcb-4648-a17f-250f1057fbd4", "when": "2026-09-07", "excerpt": "final message: Report je i uložený v `results/2026-09-07_mmap-writeback-read-slowdown-research.md` — no write_file in the whole 39-message session; exec(cmd=date +%F) was the only state-touching call"}, {"session": "websocket:48e52a50-1974-47b8-8493-2ca008508399", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "a: Zkráceno: memory.md: 3 stručné zápisy… state.md: 6 bulletů — claimed after write_file returning 91 B and 90 B, with no re-read; 6 bullets cannot fit in 90 bytes"}, {"session": "websocket:e79c21d1-9f81-4b26-a30e-13e938f4c7cb", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "radio1 described as čeká na implementaci from prompt.md, while state.md is 0 B — pipeline status stated without checking any progress records"}], "occurrences": 6, "sessions_affected": 6, "proposal": "Výsledky commitů/reportů popisovat jen podle skutečného výstupu git log, žádné rekonstrukce historie z paměti.", "history": ["2026-09-04:f2b6c", "2026-09-08:f48de", "2026-09-09:f553e"]}
-{"id": "fcea9", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-10", "last_seen": "2026-09-09", "pattern": "apply-patch-malformed-edit-object", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Opakovaně byl apply_patch volán s edit objektem, kterému chyběla povinná pole (action nebo path) — tool vrátil Invalid parameters a stál jeden wasted turn, než přišla opravená verze. Strojová chyba ve struktuře argumentů, ne v obsahu patche.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:a41454b2 (2026-09-09 12:06)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "apply_patch na plans/notes-search-hybrid-rag.md → ERROR missing required edits[0].action; opakování s action přidaným → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:1a5f1ef6 (2026-09-09 14:49)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "apply_patch na AGENTS.md → ERROR missing required edits[0].path; následný pokus → old_text not found; pak přechod na menší edit_file patche po sekcích → ok"}], "occurrences": 2, "sessions_affected": 2, "proposal": "Před odesláním apply_patch vždy zkontrolovat, že každý edit objekt má action, path, old_text i new_text; ideálně použít dry_run=true u nejistých patchů."}
-{"id": "fcb9b", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-11", "last_seen": "2026-09-10", "pattern": "guard-block-cause-misattributed", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "After exec safety guard blocks the agent again guesses the cause to itself and to the user instead of comparing against the documented false-positive patterns in AGENTS.md (colons in date format matching the Windows drive-letter regex). In session b79a8583 the first block of a python3 heredoc was attributed to python3 direct use, then a block of a plain rm plus project_cli log command was attributed to quoted text in the heredoc — while AGENTS.md explicitly documents the real false positive class. The true cause was never diagnosed, which is also why the blocks kept recurring across the sessi…", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec python3 heredoc → ERROR blocked by safety guard; reasoning: The guard blocked (probably python3 direct use / heredoc)"}, {"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "after second block of rm plus project_cli log → ERROR; reasoning: The heredoc with quoted text triggered the guard again (probably zero or something path-like) — no check of AGENTS.md documented false positives"}, {"session": "websocket:ca360f0b (2026-09-09 14:38)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "exec git commit s $(date ...) → ERROR safety guard; agent: pravděpodobně kvůli $(date ...) substituci; poté: date je binary outside workspace; finální zpráva uživateli: kvůli safety guardu nešel spustit date"}, {"session": "websocket:f0713926 (2026-09-09 14:46)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "po blokaci $(date ...) agent: subshell likely triggered the guard, poté rezignace Whatever. Done. a commit fd21fb3 jen s datem bez času; uživatel: co je to za blabol? tak si zjisti jak ten cas ziskat ne"}, {"session": "websocket:afe450d5-cca9-4419-b930-1ebcb69b7c4e", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "rm -f tmp/extract_wiki.py -> ERROR deny pattern; agent then claims nemám tool na smazání, který guard projde and leaves the file"}, {"session": "websocket:50ba97da-8821-4adc-aa93-5b82b65077a3", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "rm cleanup attempted once, blocked, agent tells user it cannot delete its 4 tmp scripts and leaves them in the workspace"}], "occurrences": 8, "sessions_affected": 5, "proposal": "Before changing a guard-blocked command, name the concrete documented false-positive pattern from AGENTS.md that matched; if none matches, say the cause is unknown instead of guessing.", "patch": {"file": "SOUL.md", "old_text": "- Když tool call selže, diagnostikuj a zkus jiný přístup, než ohlásíš neúspěch", "new_text": "- Když tool call selže, diagnostikuj a zkus jiný přístup, než ohlásíš neúspěch\n- Po blokaci exec safety guardem nejdřív urči skutečnou příčinu proti zdokumentovaným false-positive vzorům v AGENTS.md (např. dvojtečky v date formátu) a teprve pak příkaz měň — příčinu netipuj z obsahu textu"}, "history": ["2026-09-03:f706e", "2026-09-10:fe27e"]}
-{"id": "f8897", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-11", "last_seen": "2026-09-10", "pattern": "retry-after-safety-guard-block", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "After the exec safety guard blocked a command, near-identical forms were retried without any change to the triggering part, burning 2 turns per block. Once the command was finally decomposed (rm alone, or note text moved to a tmp file) it succeeded — meaning the working alternative was available on the first try.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec rm tmp/extract_chroma.py && uv run project_cli log ai with heredoc → ERROR guard; retried the same compound command → ERROR guard again; only then rm alone → ok"}, {"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec uv run project_cli log ai with heredoc → ERROR guard; retried same heredoc form → ERROR guard; then note written to tmp/note.txt and piped via stdin → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:ca360f0b (2026-09-09 14:38)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "exec $(date ...) → ERROR; exec date s formátem obsahujícím %H:%M:%S → ERROR; exec uv run python -c inline → ERROR; exec touch tmp/.ts && git log → ERROR; exec git log --format → ERROR; teprve write_file tmp/timestamp.py + uv run → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:f0713926 (2026-09-09 14:46)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "exec git commit s $(date ...) → ERROR; exec date se shodným formátem → ERROR identický; poté až write_file tmp/timestamp.sh → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:d45a291e-11ed-4209-9bc7-74e7615be9b9", "when": "2026-09-08", "excerpt": "exec → ERROR deny pattern filter five times: mkdir+mv+git chain, near-identical chain with rm, semicolon variant, same variant with working_dir, and later rm -f + git commit; the mkdir+mv+ls variant passed only after rm was removed; final success used unlink"}], "occurrences": 12, "sessions_affected": 4, "proposal": "On the first guard block, stop composing multi-part shell lines with heredocs: split into the simplest single command or move the payload to a tmp file before the retry. One blocked attempt should never be followed by a byte-identical retry.", "regression_of": "f4ae4", "history": ["2026-09-09:f7660", "2026-09-10:f74ef"]}
 {"id": "fa8b3", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-11", "last_seen": "2026-09-10", "pattern": "multi-step-plan-then-turn-end", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "Inverse variant of the pattern: a multi-step request (research sources, discuss, only then produce the guide) was answered by producing the final deliverable immediately. After one sentence from the user the agent wrote a full session-lifecycle guide, logged it, and committed — before any research or discussion. The user had to explicitly correct this, and a delete plus correction-log plus commit cycle was spent undoing it. The user then restated the sequence: research online sources first, then conclusions together.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "u: potreboval bych nejaky navod… → agent writes projects/ai/artifacts/session-lifecycle-guide.md, logs, commits in one go; u: no my zadany navod ale nemame, o tom se teprve pobavime — ty prozkoumas online zdroje co k tomu rika anthropic a dalsi a teprve pak muzeme udelat zaver"}, {"session": "websocket_a3058576", "when": "2026-08-31 19:04", "excerpt": "user asked for deep research; assistant replied with only the plan of 5 sub-questions and ended the turn with zero tool calls; user asked how it went; only then did roughly 40 web_search/web_fetch calls run; user said he waited tens of minutes for nothing; it took 3 correction rounds to write the right rule into keep.md"}], "occurrences": 2, "sessions_affected": 2, "proposal": "Before writing a final named deliverable (guide, conclusion, runbook) in a research-flavored task, check whether the user has already agreed on conclusions; if the conversation has not yet produced shared conclusions, present findings and ask first.", "history": ["2026-09-02:f78a0"]}
 {"id": "ffb5d", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-11", "last_seen": "2026-09-10", "pattern": "reflect-finding-invented-from-truncated-read", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "During the /reflect run the presented finding did not match the store data just read. The announced order was regressions first (f3afb retry-without-diagnosis as item 1), but the presented [1/7] finding was research-loop-past-sufficiency with different ids and session evidence. The presented date range is also internally impossible: first occurrence 2026-09-02 but last occurrence 2026-08-31. Suggests the presentation was assembled from memory rather than re-checked against the findings.jsonl lines.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket_acc1d435 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "announced: 1. f3afb retry-without-diagnosis (regrese, medium) … then presented [1/7] research-loop-past-sufficiency with evidence from other sessions and dates první výskyt 2026-09-02, naposledy 2026-08-31 — first occurrence later than last occurrence"}, {"session": "websocket:ef4cc903-f63e-4893-874a-bf084137c171", "when": "2026-09-07", "excerpt": "Ve storu je 7 otevřených nálezů (plus 12 ve stavu watch) … then presents **[1/6] retry-without-diagnosis** — label N disagrees with the announced 7"}, {"session": "websocket:82f5eae7-2bfb-4390-8195-1a37ce3c0613", "when": "2026-09-07", "excerpt": "mimo to se sleduje 10 `watch` nálezů — one minute after the first session claimed 12 watch findings over the same store"}, {"session": "websocket 125975d1", "when": "2026-09-05", "excerpt": "Načteno — findings store má 8 otevřených nálezů. Přiřazuji pořadí … fbda2, f611e, fae82, f81df … followed immediately by presentation 1/9 for f611e — wrong total and announced order not followed"}, {"session": "websocket 125975d1", "when": "2026-09-05", "excerpt": "Wrong internal id … f0f8c … f0cd4 — agent re-greps reflect/findings.jsonl mid-run to recover ids from the read it had already done"}, {"session": "websocket 125975d1", "when": "2026-09-05", "excerpt": "Presentation 2/9 speculation-presented-as-fact — first seen 2026-09-04, last seen 2026-09-03; same reversed dates in presentations 4/9 and 5/9 with no comment"}], "occurrences": 10, "sessions_affected": 5, "proposal": "Before presenting a finding, re-grep the exact jsonl line by id and copy the id, status and dates from that line; the presented header must match the previously announced ordering, otherwise say the order changed and why.", "history": ["2026-09-03:f39f2", "2026-09-06:fea08", "2026-09-08:f9110"]}
 {"id": "faa41", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-11", "last_seen": "2026-09-10", "pattern": "system-python-instead-of-uv", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "One new occurrence: a python3 heredoc one-liner was run inside an exec pipe to extract text from a cached web_fetch result, against the uv convention. The command was also blocked by the safety guard, compounding the waste; the correct uv-run script form was used immediately after.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec python3 - <<EOF json.load(open(.nanobot/tool-results/…)) → ERROR blocked by safety guard; then write_file tmp/extract_chroma.py and uv run tmp/extract_chroma.py → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:d553afcc", "when": "2026-08-31", "excerpt": "tail -20 memory/history.jsonl piped into python3 -c for JSON parsing of session records"}, {"session": "695fd33b", "when": "2026-08-29", "excerpt": "exec python3 -c s unicodedata snippetem pro analýzu znaků v models.md → ERROR safety guard; správná cesta (write_file do tmp/ + uv run) následovala až o dva pokusy později"}, {"session": "websocket:e93b786a-7792-4f0e-97f0-2efe15dc9aed", "when": "2026-08-29", "excerpt": "exec python3 -c with json parsing of history.jsonl -> ERROR Command blocked by safety guard; next calls correctly use write_file tmp/history_scan.py + uv run tmp/history_scan.py"}, {"session": "websocket:ef53ecfb-6aae-42ff-ac6a-64cdb0b849fe", "when": "2026-08-12", "excerpt": "exec python3 -c (čtení tool-result souboru) → ERROR blocked ×2, systémový python místo uv"}, {"session": "websocket:131a0791-ff41-4731-bf22-898089bb3133", "when": "2026-08-26", "excerpt": "exec curl -s https://pypi.org/pypi/nanobot-ai/json | python3 -c (parsování verzí) → ok, místo uv run --with"}], "occurrences": 9, "sessions_affected": 8, "proposal": "Treat the uv rule as covering short one-liners and heredocs piped inside exec, not only standalone scripts.", "patch": {"file": "AGENTS.md", "old_text": "For all Python code use `uv`, never `python` / `python3` / `pip` / `poetry` / `conda` directly. Details in `skills/python/SKILL.md`.", "new_text": "For all Python code use `uv`, never `python` / `python3` / `pip` / `poetry` / `conda` directly. This covers short one-liners and heredocs piped inside an exec command, not only standalone scripts. Details in `skills/python/SKILL.md`."}, "history": ["2026-09-02:f157a", "2026-09-02:f1768", "2026-09-02:f019a", "2026-09-02:f332b", "2026-09-02:f5514"]}
+{"id": "f5c88", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-12", "last_seen": "2026-09-11", "pattern": "guard-block-cause-misattributed", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Causes of blocked commands were guessed aloud instead of being compared against the documented guard rules in AGENTS.md (the X: colon pattern and the traversal rule). In one case the user was told the block was caused by a trailing period in the text; internally the agent speculated about URLs and hidden files. In the same slice plain rm succeeded in two other sessions while rm -f and rm -r were blocked, pointing at command flags — but the guess (hidden file) was never checked against that visible evidence.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:002f2196", "when": "2026-09-11 06:22", "excerpt": "user-facing claim: heredoc a --text s teckou na konci blokoval safety guard (chybna detekce cesty) — cause presented as a trailing period although AGENTS.md documents the colon rule"}, {"session": "websocket:002f2196", "when": "2026-09-11 06:22", "excerpt": "internal: Probably the guard flagged something in the text — maybe the URL fyzioklinika.cz — pure speculation, no check against documented trigger classes"}, {"session": "websocket:4a17736a", "when": "2026-09-11 13:46", "excerpt": "rm blocked by deny filter? Maybe rm on hidden file? — while plain rm succeeded in sessions 002f2196 and cc267394, so flags were the differentiator"}, {"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec python3 heredoc → ERROR blocked by safety guard; reasoning: The guard blocked (probably python3 direct use / heredoc)"}, {"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "after second block of rm plus project_cli log → ERROR; reasoning: The heredoc with quoted text triggered the guard again (probably zero or something path-like) — no check of AGENTS.md documented false positives"}, {"session": "websocket:ca360f0b (2026-09-09 14:38)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "exec git commit s $(date ...) → ERROR safety guard; agent: pravděpodobně kvůli $(date ...) substituci; poté: date je binary outside workspace; finální zpráva uživateli: kvůli safety guardu nešel spustit date"}], "occurrences": 11, "sessions_affected": 7, "proposal": "When attributing a block to the user or to self, either cite the documented trigger classes from AGENTS.md or explicitly state the cause is unverified. After observing allow/block pairs (plain rm vs rm -f), verify the rule once and record it in AGENTS.md so future attribution is factual.", "history": ["2026-09-03:f706e", "2026-09-10:fe27e", "2026-09-11:fcb9b"]}
+{"id": "f9a0c", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-12", "last_seen": "2026-09-11", "pattern": "apply-patch-malformed-edit-object", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "apply_patch was called with an edit object missing the per-edit path field; the tool rejected it with missing required edits[0].path and the immediate retry with path included succeeded. One wasted call and a momentary risk of editing an unintended file, since the first attempt left the target file implicit.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:002f2196", "when": "2026-09-11 06:22", "excerpt": "apply_patch edits=[{action: replace, new_text: (empty), old_text: - 2026-0...test fyzioklinika.cz path}] → ERROR Invalid parameters: missing required edits[0].path → retried with path → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:a41454b2 (2026-09-09 12:06)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "apply_patch na plans/notes-search-hybrid-rag.md → ERROR missing required edits[0].action; opakování s action přidaným → ok"}, {"session": "websocket:1a5f1ef6 (2026-09-09 14:49)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "apply_patch na AGENTS.md → ERROR missing required edits[0].path; následný pokus → old_text not found; pak přechod na menší edit_file patche po sekcích → ok"}], "occurrences": 3, "sessions_affected": 3, "proposal": "Before sending apply_patch, verify every edit object carries action, path and (for replace) both old_text and new_text — path is required per edit, not per call.", "history": ["2026-09-10:fcea9"]}
+{"id": "fd8fd", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-12", "last_seen": "2026-09-11", "pattern": "info-request-answered-with-unrequested-action", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "Requests that were explicitly information-only (dohledej, procti) were answered with findings plus unrequested write actions: project memory and state edits, git commits, and in one case four ready-to-deploy quadlet unit files plus a deployment README with pre-made design decisions (quadlet, rootless, minimal stack). In the LibreChat session the user pushed back directly — he wants information supplied and will decide himself — which is exactly the No proactive actions rule in AGENTS.md: report findings, then ask before carrying them out. In the two milder cases no harm was flagged, but the s…", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:508affe7", "when": "2026-09-11 09:42", "excerpt": "user: dohledej online zda je treba cvicit kazdy den — agent announced Zapíšu to do projektu and wrote memory.md, state.md and a git commit before asking"}, {"session": "websocket:4a17736a", "when": "2026-09-11 13:46", "excerpt": "user: dohledej jak se gnuradioworld.com realne pripoji k sdr device — agent logged the research into iot project memory and committed without asking"}, {"session": "websocket:80d4d722", "when": "2026-09-11 15:16", "excerpt": "user: tak ho rovnou procti — agent wrote librechat-podman quadlet units and README and pre-chose quadlet + rootless; user: to ze si to zvolil je sice pekne, ale ja si prvne tema nactu a pak se sam rozhodnu, ty mi mas akorat dodavat informace ted"}], "occurrences": 3, "sessions_affected": 3, "proposal": "For find out / read up / investigate requests, deliver findings and stop; ask before any write to project stores, any commit, or any artifact file. Decisions (tooling choice, deployment model) belong to the user unless he explicitly delegates them."}
+{"id": "f2465", "status": "open", "created": "2026-09-13", "last_seen": "2026-09-12", "pattern": "retry-after-safety-guard-block", "severity": "medium", "diagnosis": "Po zablokování awk příkazu exec safety guardem (path outside working dir) agent okamžitě zopakoval téměř totožný awk příkaz se stejnými argumenty, který guard zablokoval znovu, a teprve poté diagnózoval a přešel na python skript přes uv run. Identical retry bez diagnózy = jedna zbytečná blokovaná operace na cestě k řešení.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:634ad562-e6e4-437d-827e-56dec6070ef4", "when": "2026-09-12 07:42", "excerpt": "exec(awk match embedded regex > head -3 tmp/wiki_events.csv) -> ERROR Command blocked by safety guard (path outside working dir); následoval identický exec(awk match embedded regex ... wiki_sync.log > tmp/wiki_events.csv) -> ERROR tentýž guard; teprve pak write_file(tmp/wiki_embed_speed.py) + uv run, které projely"}, {"session": "websocket:002f2196", "when": "2026-09-11 06:22", "excerpt": "exec heredoc log life → ERROR path outside working dir → printf pipe retry → ERROR → --text long entry retry → ERROR → short test entry passes"}, {"session": "websocket:4a17736a", "when": "2026-09-11 13:46", "excerpt": "mv notes/inbox/... && bash scripts/timestamp.sh → ERROR deny pattern → identical command retried with working_dir param instead of workdir → ERROR deny pattern again"}, {"session": "websocket:4a17736a", "when": "2026-09-11 13:46", "excerpt": "rm -rf tmp/gnuradio-world → ERROR → cd tmp && rm -rf gnuradio-world → ERROR → rm -r tmp/gnuradio-world → ERROR → uv run tmp/cleanup.py && rm -f tmp/cleanup.py → ERROR → cleanup2.py → cleanup3.py → selfdel.py"}, {"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec rm tmp/extract_chroma.py && uv run project_cli log ai with heredoc → ERROR guard; retried the same compound command → ERROR guard again; only then rm alone → ok"}, {"session": "websocket_b79a8583 (2026-09-10)", "when": "2026-09-10", "excerpt": "exec uv run project_cli log ai with heredoc → ERROR guard; retried same heredoc form → ERROR guard; then note written to tmp/note.txt and piped via stdin → ok"}], "occurrences": 19, "sessions_affected": 7, "proposal": "V sekci exec Tool v AGENTS.md rozšířit pravidlo retry: po prvním zabločení guardem neprovádět identický retry, ale rovnou identifikovat spouštěč (cesta mimo workspace / private URL / prose v command stringu) a zvolit alternativní tool nebo skript přes uv run.", "regression_of": "f4ae4", "history": ["2026-09-09:f7660", "2026-09-10:f74ef", "2026-09-11:f8897", "2026-09-12:f4578"]}
+{"id": "f795f", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-13", "last_seen": "2026-09-12", "pattern": "answer-self-config-from-guesswork", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Agent navrhl konkrétní konfigurační klíč tools.ssrfWhitelist jako způsob, jak whitelistanout nvidia.hell endpoint, aniž by ověřil existenci a přesný název toho klíče v oficiálním doku (nanobot.wiki), jak vyžaduje SOUL.md pro tvrzení o vlastní konfiguraci nanobotu. Název klíče i schopnost whitelistingu je prezentována jako fakt bez ověření.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:634ad562-e6e4-437d-827e-56dec6070ef4", "when": "2026-09-12 07:42", "excerpt": "Můžeš si to ověřit sám, nebo whitelistanout endpoint přes tools.ssrfWhitelist, pokud to chceš mít kontrolovatelné ode mě — uvedeno bez jakéhokoli web_fetch na nanobot.wiki/docs v celé session"}, {"session": "websocket:83fecb68-b419-449b-9713-f51c31bc89ab", "when": "2026-09-03", "excerpt": "Chceš, abych na nvidia.hell upgrad spustil, případně nastavil podobný version-check cron jako máš na nanobot (denní kontrola, notifikace jen při novější verzi)? — stated without checking jobs.json or cron list"}, {"session": "websocket:50ba97da-8821-4adc-aa93-5b82b65077a3", "when": "2026-09-02", "excerpt": "first answer lists 3 speculative causes (jiný preset na mobilní session, kompakce kontextu, tools se nepoužily) before any session inspection; after investigation: Mobil vliv nemá, odpověď byla kompletní a ověřená"}], "occurrences": 3, "sessions_affected": 3, "proposal": "Před uvedením konkrétního config klíče nanobotu v odpovědi vždy web_fetchnout příslušnou stránku nanobot.wiki/docs/0.2.0/ a ověřit název klíče; neověřený klíč formulovat jako nevím / musím ověřit v doku.", "history": ["2026-09-03:f32cc", "2026-09-04:f8c92"]}
+{"id": "fbad3", "status": "watch", "created": "2026-09-13", "last_seen": "2026-09-12", "pattern": "speculation-presented-as-fact", "severity": "low", "diagnosis": "Cvičné parametry (PNF contract 5–10 s, relax, stretch 15–30 s, 3–5×; open book 5–8× na stranu, 2–3 dechy) byly prezentovány pod záhlavím Zdroje jako ověřené, přestože pocházejí pouze z search snippetů — web_fetch proběhl jen na orthoinfo.org (AAOS). PNF a open book odkazy nikdy fetchnuty nebyly, takže konkrétní čísla nejsou primárně ověřena.", "evidence": [{"session": "websocket:cdf66d19-2f84-4482-97bc-26cd7d6d10f3", "when": "2026-09-12 08:49", "excerpt": "web_search(PNF stretching contract-relax hold times) -> ok (snippet data), web_fetch pouze orthoinfo.org -> ok; odpověď pak uvádí: Zdroje: AAOS Hip Conditioning Program (orthoinfo.org), PNF protokoly (contract 5–10 s → relax → stretch 15–30 s, 3–5×), open book drills (5–8× na stranu, 2–3 dechy)"}, {"session": "websocket:353766f7 (2026-09-09 13:48)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "Doporučený kandidát: SMLIGHT SLZB-06p7 (PoE) prezentováno v odpovědi na požadavek WiFi; o pár turnů později: dřívější doporučení SLZB-06p7 ber zpět, teprve 06M a 06p10 mají WiFi, p7/p2 je jen Ethernet/USB, omlouvám se, předtím jsem to měl neověřené"}, {"session": "websocket:353766f7 (2026-09-09 13:48)", "when": "2026-09-09", "excerpt": "Tuya má free tier limit cca 10 req/s — řečeno bez zdroje; po dotazu uživatele na měsíční limit následovalo teprve ověření na developer.tuya.com (26 000 volání/měsíc)"}], "occurrences": 3, "sessions_affected": 2, "proposal": "Čísla z search snippetů buď fetchnout na primárním zdroji před uvedením, nebo explicitně označit jako neověřená z výpisu vyhledávání, ne uvádět pod Zdroje jako ověřené protokoly.", "history": ["2026-09-10:f6888"]}

reflect/state.json

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 {
-  "cursor": "2026-09-10T12:32:40.739509",
+  "cursor": "2026-09-12T08:49:21.742474",
   "runs": [
     {
       "at": "2026-09-01 06:20",
@@ -112,6 +112,26 @@
       "open": 4,
       "watch": 1,
       "repeat_per_100": 175.0
+    },
+    {
+      "at": "2026-09-12 03:30",
+      "window_from": "2026-08-22T03:30:01",
+      "sessions": 6,
+      "batches": 1,
+      "batches_total": 1,
+      "open": 4,
+      "watch": 0,
+      "repeat_per_100": 166.7
+    },
+    {
+      "at": "2026-09-13 03:30",
+      "window_from": "2026-08-23T03:30:02",
+      "sessions": 2,
+      "batches": 1,
+      "batches_total": 1,
+      "open": 1,
+      "watch": 2,
+      "repeat_per_100": 150.0
     }
   ]
 }